Should Small Businesses Prioritize Growth or Profitability? The Sustainable Approach
Should Small Businesses Prioritize Growth or Profitability? The Sustainable Approach
For many small business owners, a common question that arises is whether to focus more effort on rapid growth or on maintaining profitability. Often times, these two goals can seem opposed to one another in the early days of a business. Growth usually requires substantial reinvestment of revenue into things like additional staffing, equipment, marketing and expansion expenses. As a result, profit margins can suffer in the short-term while the infrastructure for faster scaling is put into place.
On the flip side, an obsessive focus on strong profitability right out the gate may restrict the capacity a company has to invest in growth. Early profits may pad the balance sheet in the first year or two, but almost always at the expense of stunted expansion in later years. So which approach is the right one for small business owners seeking sustainability?
The Sustainable Path is Growth-Focused but Prudently Profit-Conscious
Rather than viewing growth and profit as mutually exclusive, small businesses should take an integrated strategic approach. The priority should first be on growth – more specifically, on sustainable growth that establishes a healthy momentum and platform for longevity.
But sustainable growth cannot happen without some degree of profit-consciousness guiding investment decisions and operating principles. By coupling an aggressive focus on scalability with prudent financial discipline, small companies can often extend their runway long enough to start realizing the profitable payoffs.
Reinvesting Rather than Extracting Early on
In the early days of a startup or small enterprise, positive cash flow and profit – while welcome – is far from essential. As Amazon’s Jeff Bezos famously stated in the early years, “It’s not an experiment if you know it’s going to work.” What he meant by that quote is that rapid growth for a young company depends on taking risks and reinvesting all profits rather than extracting them.
As many small business entrepreneurs know, it takes money to make money. Generating a profit too early on can be a curse if owners use that as justification to pull out capital or declare dividends rather than pouring it back into expansion experiments. Startups need several years of reinvested profits to hit an inflection point where rapid growth at scale can happen. Small enterprises should follow comparable principles, even if not venture-backed and focused more on local ownership and community impact.
Knowing When to Push for Profitability
However, that isn’t to say profitability should be ignored completely in those developmental years. Savvy small business owners will operate on shoestring budgets, keep close tabs on operating expenses versus revenue, and have a clear benchmark in mind for when they’ll need to throttle back on growth and focus more on cash preservation. Being overly cavalier about profitability, even while pursuing growth, is a common pitfall for entrepreneurs. Not every growth avenue merits heavy investment, especially when product-market fit remains uncertain. Many growth pivots will inevitably lead to dead ends.
The takeaway is that small business owners should obsess less about growth versus profit tradeoffs. If affordable growth plans seem reasonably likely to deliver customer adoption and loyalty at higher volumes, it merits aggressive reinvestment for perhaps 2-3 years until clarity on whether the model is sustainable emerges. But prudent cost management allows for longer runways. By the third or fourth year, expectations should shift toward positive operating margins or gradual reductions in debt dependence. Sustainability ultimately requires a dual growth and profitability mindset.
Signs Growth Plans Are Becoming Unsustainable
Projecting when growth will translate to profit is more art than science for small businesses. But there are a few key signals a pivot toward optimizing profits may be necessary:
• Customer Acquisition Costs Mount: If the cost to acquire each new customer creeps steadily upward, it suggests a saturated niche where more marketing spend ceases to be prudent. Existing customers have to become profitable over shorter time horizons through either price hikes or cost-cutting elsewhere.
• Churn Rates Increase: When existing customers begin leaving faster than replacements materialize, it’s a warning growth may have tapped out. Higher churn means less efficient use of resources on hand. Prioritizing better customer targeting, onboarding, or retention capabilities helps optimize client profitability.
• External Funding Access Declines: If small business credit lines face reductions, loan applications get denied more often, investors turn elsewhere, or even friends/family seed money dries up, it can indicate stakeholders question future profitability. The growth strategy requires revisiting.
• Talent Hiring and Retention Gets Harder: Difficulty filling open roles, or rising turnover among staff, signals that employees themselves may see flaws in the business execution or lack confidence it can become sustainably profitable. Their firsthand insights merit addressing.
While giving growth a consistent priority over profit, savvy small business owners monitor for the above indicators that plans might exceed sustainable capacities. Early detection allows for pivots before runway length or reputational credibility face irreparable damage. But with prudent financial stewardship, the growth over profit approach truly does offer the most promising pathway toward building an impactful and profitable enterprise over the long haul for small businesses.
-Jason
Use The Links Below to Help Support this blog and our podcast
Commission Earned